The Downfall of Brian McDermott

Clive Mason

Having had a little bit of time to digest the sacking of Brian McDermott, it's left for us to ponder just where it all went wrong for a man labelled as 'god' by some Reading fans less than a year ago. This wasn't a slow lingering death like the Coppell era but a brutal jarring end to one of the best runs in our history, but how did it happen? Here's six key reasons things went south for our former manager.

The team just got worse

Funnily enough the day before Brian was sacked I'd started writing an article about how Brian's teams were capable of playing decent attacking football if they had the right personel. The shocking thing for me was how far the quality in our first XI has dropped over his tenure despite almost unprecedented success.

Consider this lineup that thrashed Preston 4-1 on the final day of Brian's first season in the job in 2010.

A Federici, M Mills, A Griffin (J Karacan, 84), R Bertrand, A Pearce , J McAnuff, J Tabb, B Howard (B Gunnarsson, 68), J Kebe, G Sigurdsson , S Long (S Church, 85)

Is it just me or do you not think that the team above is superior to the one that lined up against Villa this past weekend?

Pearce and Tabb are much of a muchness, Brian Howard is maybe a wash with Leigertwood but otherwise I almost universally prefer that team. Kebe and McAnuff were younger, you had superstars (for our level) in Long, Bertrand and Sigurdsson while Mills was as capable as Mariappa and Griffin was as good as Kelly has been in his short spell.

My question is how on earth have we ended up with a weaker starting XI despite two cup quarter-finals, a play-off final and promotion to the Premier League?!

A lot of the fault has to go on the owners but then that's not exactly fair on Sir John, who openly said he had no more money to put in and didn't want to gamble with our financial future.

With Anton Zingarevich it's another story and probably a debate that will rage long beyond our fate this season. Needless to say his investment has hardly been superior to anything we saw under Sir John.

The likes of Long, Bertrand and Sigurdsson were just never replaced, while we've not seen the raw quality of a Jimmy Kebe style player signed either. Prospects like Church have lingered too long while how Bryn was still in our 25-man squad is beyond me, which leads me on to point two.

Too much faith in the old guard

Mikele Leigertwood, Jason Roberts, Kaspars Gorkss... what do they all have in common? Answer, they were discarded by Premier League teams last season.

The reasons for that are varied but whatever way you look at it, QPR (finished 17th) and Blackburn (relegated) all thought they could do without them. Now, I appreciate that sometimes players just don't gel at a club and I was probably one of many who wondered why Warnock had disguarded Gorkss, but his decision was vindicated by the fact that he's now been bombed out on loan to Wolves halfway into the season.

Leigertwood has been relegated twice, and then disguarded after promotion by QPR. While Jason Roberts was let go by a Blackburn team who were heading for the drop.

I can't possibly praise the three of them highly enough for the role they played in our promotion and as squad players they all could have had a role in our 25-man squad, but not as starters every week.

You could probably throw Jobi McAnuff, Jay Tabb and Noel Hunt into this mix as players who've never been in the Premier League and you have to say we now know why.

These are all top, honest, hard working pros who deserved a shot and perhaps a squad role but not at the sake of our Premier League survival and certainly not picking up the runs in the first team that they have this year.

What made this worse was the sacrificing of players who had Premier League quality, or at least potential for most of the season. McAnuff and Leigertwood were undroppable while Gorkss was kept in ahead of Pearce despite looking woefully out of his depth.

Roberts was kept in the 25-man squad despite a chronic hip injury at 35 and didn't score a goal last season. I'm sorry but when the man who got you up from the Championship by looking a class above his three team-mates is ineffective... what does it tell you about the other three? Simon Church was duly dispatched, but that left Noel Hunt and Adam Le Fondre to remain, strengthened only by Pavel Pogrebnyak, veteran of less than half a Premier League season, and speaking of the Pog.

Ineffective signings

While I've lamented how our squad has failed to improve, Brian hasn't exactly bought brilliantly in his time here.

Brian's new signings this season had combined to start just 45% of the available games this season, hardly a ringing endorsement of his recruitment. Of his summer signings Nicky Shorey, Danny Guthrie, Pavel Pogrebnyak, Garath McCleary, Chris Gunter, Daniel Carrico and Nick Blackman have ALL been dropped repeatedly and it's only really Adrian Mariappa that's really lived up to his fees and wages this season. Whether the rest COULD and SHOULD be playing is another question but if Brian doesn't have the confidence to play them, well then he's either bought badly or is a bad judge of character/talent and either way it's played a part in his downfall.

How any manager could go into a Premier League season with Jay Tabb as your fourth best midfielder is poor, especially when two of the three above him are the aforementioned PL reject Leigertwood and an untested Jem Karacan. That's just poor squad construction plain and simple.

Throw into the mix busts like Mathieu Manset, Jo Mills, Karl Sheppard, Brett & Marcus Williams and it's not a ringing endorsement for the man.

That being said, he did sign players like Andy Griffin, Leigertwood, Adam Le Fondre and Hope Akpan so it's not been total failure on the transfer front.

Again, this is an area where you have to ask what was available to him and who he may have passed on. If he was given no money then I guess you get what you (don't) pay for but if he did have funds to spend or had more choice... well he's picked badly. When a man who cost the club over £2 million is out of the squad within six months it doesn't look good put it that way.

A victim of his own success

Brian's barely known a crisis at this football club. When he joined the club were in a bad position, left in a state of chaos after the failure of Brendan Rodgers' three year six month plan.

To survive that season would have been seen as a success but the spectacular run that saw us smash teams like Sheffield Wednesday, Derby and Peterborough and then get to within 45 minutes of an FA Cup semi-final raised expectations quickly.

The departure of Sigurdsson helped lower them but an astonishing run to Wembley raised them once again and Brian suddenly had nothing but success on his CV.

A month into the 2011/12 season and suddenly the mood had changed. The departure of Long & Matt Mills left us short of quality in key areas and the team sat second from bottom of the Championship. Brian once again worked wonders, turning those £11m worth of sales into a solid team by spending just 10% of it, on the likes of Gorkss, J Mills and Adam Le Fondre. The return to form of key players like Leigertwood and McAnuff helped but it was only the arrival of TSI and with them Jason Roberts that suddenly turned us into Championship contenders.

Lets be honest though... who looked at our team during that run and thought... yeah that's a Championship winning team? While our ability to get results was fantastic, it was a run that had more than a few strokes of good fortune. The backs to the wall win at Brighton helped by a Federici penalty save, the win over Forest helped by a block on the line by Pearce, West Ham choking just before half-time at Upton Park, Roberts fluking a rebound from a dire penalty against Bristol City or even likes of Coventry being denied by a superb goalkeeping display by Federici. Now you can of course argue how much those were down to 'luck' but we weren't dominating sides and you can't tell me we'd win those games 9/10 as true juggernaughts such as our 2005/06 squad or Newcastle back in 2009/10 would.

The squad that went up was a plucky, Championship savy side but one that was wholly unprepared for the top level. This wasn't a young untested squad in their prime that just needed a chance like in 2005/06. As mentioned, this was a team full of perennial Championship dwellers, PL cast-offs and youngsters.

However, when you're in the Premier League it's easy to forget such things and suddenly a manager is expected to paint a masterpiece on MS Paint, or build a solid hurricane proof house out of sticks and prit stick.

Brian never had a chance to build a Premier League ready side, he just had a good Championship side that was capable of going on a good run. West Ham showed that you can have PL quality but struggle for consistency because of inexperience and sadly Reading have been found out as having just the opposite, solid consistency but a lack of quality beyond that.

Had Brian been given £8m in the Championship could he have bought a few more players whom given 12 months would have been PL ready? Debatable but I'd fancy us to survive with a team that contained a full year of Championship tested Blackman, Akpan, Cummings etc more than this one.

Premier League Naivety & Stubbornness

Brian never really seemed comfortable with the media spotlight this season and just didn't seem to know how to handle tricky situations on and off the field.

Off the pitch he never got to grips with the increased egos and demands of players once they're in the Premier League. His stalwart goalkeeper Adam Federici kicked off and broke ranks over why he was dropped/injured whatever. Then came repeated bust-ups with Danny Guthrie and a reported falling out with Jason Roberts after the Southampton game... funnily enough we haven't seen Roberts since.

Add to the mix the problems with selecting Alex Pearce and you have a backroom nightmare. I'm still not sure who told or advised Brian to drop him, I've been told by sources close to the club that it came from Nick Hammond but if that's the case then why is Brian letting others make key selection policies?

The tactics and team selections were also routed in the past. Time and time again Brian went to players that had done well in a lower league rather then test the potential or place faith in those who had extra quality. To try and play 4-4-2 in the Premier League when your strikers are average and your central midfield paper-thin was suicide.

There was never a midgame change of plan either. Reading have dropped 24 points from winning positions but how often did you see the team go 4-5-1 and try to hold the lead? There was never any creativity or even attempt to change things, the best we ever got was putting Jobi McAnuff into the middle and throwing on another striker.

When he did change things, shock horror things picked up. Of our 23 points this season, 14 have come in games where we started 4-5-1 and yet once again we've gone back to the well bested 4-4-2.

Reading have just never seemed to have a different way of playing and while I think that's in part down to the quality of player available, the lack of an attempt to change was disappointing.

Bad luck or the absence of good luck

It's not exactly been a great year for us on the luck front. Whether it's our previously solid 'keeper dropping two clangers in the first two games, his replacement diving into a post or a handball goal being allowed to stand, we've just not had it our way for most of the year.

I could go on and on with these examples. Torres scoring an offside goal, a marginal offside call going against us last Saturday, clear penalties at Stoke and Everton not being given or Barry's questionable climb on Shorey, the rub of the green hasn't really gone our way time after time.

Now I know things have gone our way from time to time but you only need one or two of the above bad bits of luck to go our way and it's a different season entirely.

Brian also had awful luck with injuries this season. Federici, McCarthy, Karacan, Mariappa, Kebe, Shorey, Guthrie, Roberts, Pogrebnyak, Robson-Kanu and Hunt have all been injured at points this season and when your squad is as devoid of quality as ours... those injuries are utterly devastating. Again some of these players have been ignored even when available but at key times they've all been unavailable.

In conclusion

Brian's downfall has plenty to do with his own mistakes but more than a small part of it is down to bad luck or circumstances beyond his control. The lack of funds given to build a team capable of competing in the Premier League is obvious but Brian didn't help himself by buying poorly when given limited funds.

LIkewise, he had players at his disposal to change certain games but chose to ignore them, or gave too many chances to players that had shown themselves just not up to the top division.

When you add in bad luck on the pitch and in the treatment room plus backroom bust-ups and there was only one way our season was going to go.

As mentioned elsewhere, Brian has become the fifth man of the last six to guide his team up automatically to get sacked before the end of the following season. The expectations and demands of the Premier League just seem to go up and up and few managers who ply their trade in the Championship seem capable of rising to match those demands.

I think that given time and money, Brian would have risen to meet those challenges but his first attempt was admittedly poor and Anton Zingarevich obviously didn't feel that he'd get any better.

With the above it's easy to see why the decision was made but I guess it comes down to whether you think given time and money that Brian could change and adapt or if you think he's a limited manager who's mistakes have just outweighed his successes.

Whatever the case I can only thank Brian for what he's done and hope that he goes on to lead another team in the Premier League.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join The Tilehurst End

You must be a member of The Tilehurst End to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at The Tilehurst End. You should read them.

Join The Tilehurst End

You must be a member of The Tilehurst End to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at The Tilehurst End. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.