Having given you the entire first-team squad to choose from, we now count down the order for a spot-kick decider.
No. 1: Pavel Pogrebnyak - 85%
To kick us off, you've chosen the Reliable-Russian, storming home with 121 of your votes. He's off League Cup miss off a 100% penalty record for the Royals, and is apparently the fans most popular penalty taker. His style is effortlessly ice-cool, hard-and-low, and generally successful.
No. 2: Nick Blackman - 67.6%
To think that two thirds of Reading fans would back Nick Blackman to do anything positive this 18 months ago is somewhat of a miracle in itself. Still, the attacker's penalty exploits has accounted for half of his goals this season -which might be more were it not for Glenn Murray at Sheffield Wednesday!
No. 3: Yakubu - 60%
Feeding the Yak is easy when no one is allowed to stop him pelting the ball into the net from a spot-kick, and it's easy to understand why 85 of you want the Nigerian to take a pressure penalty. All that experience, all that prowess, all that history - oh.
No 4: Jamie Mackie - 50%
This man is on such a hot-streak, it's no surprise that he's in this first-five. Never really associated with penalties, but the passion of the man should see him through such a situation - although don't hold me to that *cough* John Terry *cough* Stuart Pearce...
No 5: Hal Robson-Kanu - 47%
Just trailing the Scottish winger is the ever-unpredictable HRK. This man could have a nothing game and score the winning penalty, and it shouldn't suprise any one of us. Let's just hope he doesn't miss, like his last one, then...
If your votes are to be sorted into a likely line-up for the remaining six takers (forgetting formation), here's how it could line up:
Oli Norwood - 42%
Simon Cox - 31%
Garath McCleary - 26%
Danny Williams - 25%
Nathaniel Chalobah - 20%
Jordan Obita - 15%
Honourable mentions go to Adam Federici beating the majority of his back-four to 5% of votes, while poor-old Stephen Kelly was not selected by anyone, the only player to not be picked.
So, does this make you confident of a penalty shoot-out win - if need be? Comment below.